- Play Hard
- 20th Feb 2026
- 0
- 0 minute
9 of the best places for pizza in the Tees Valley
Pizza is one of the most universally loved foods and there’s a fantastic collection of places in the Tees Valley to grab a slice, no matter how you like it.
While some of us swear by a paper-thin, crisp base, there are others who love nothing more than a thick, doughy crust that barely fits on the plate. You might be a purist ordering a simple marinara with no cheese at all, or someone who believes toppings should be piled up to the max.
Luckily, this list of the best places for pizza in the Tees Valley caters to every kind of pizza lover, so take a list to find out where you should try next.
Greedy Ted’s
5 Church Street, Guisborough, TS14 6HG
The idea for Greedy Ted’s came after the owners decided to fuse their spaniel’s (Ted) love for food with their passion for authentic Neapolitan pizza. Set in the beautiful town of Guisborough, this restaurant is bright and fresh during the day, and cosy and intimate by night, with twinkly fairy lights and snug corners to tuck into. The pizza menu is extensive with something for absolutely everyone, from a classic margherita to the adventurous stracciatella and hot honey.
Finzi
80 High Street, Yarm, TS15 9AH
Finzi is a perfect pick for a pizza lunch in Yarm. Owned by a family from the Veneto region of Northern Italy, this spot prides itself on bringing a true taste of Italian food to the Tees Valley. They often introduce lesser-known flavours and ingredients too, so the menu is always kept fresh and exciting. Their slices are served in squares, alongside extra snacks like suppli and cannoli, so they’re perfect to take away and eat while you explore the town.
Crust
4 Ridley Mews, Norton, Stockton-on-Tees, TS20 1DW
Crust is a true hidden gem in the leafy village of Norton. By day, you can visit for their famous pizza sandwiches over lunch time, with their handmade dough folded and stuffed with all kinds of fillings. And on Thursday to Saturday evenings, they open their pizza kitchen for relaxed dining with beer and wine. It’s a small but mighty spot with a warm, moody feel, making it ideal for a date night.
No. 5 New York Pizza
5 The Front, Seaton Carew, TS25 1BS
If you’re looking for a laidback, casual place that’s perfect for sharing slices with friends, look no further than No. 5 New York Pizza. Their huge pizzas are designed to take centre stage and be split amongst a group, with the restaurant recommending one pizza between two to three people. They’re all about the New York style, so think thin, crispy and paired amazingly with a range of dips. Don’t miss the tenders and fries to make a real meal of it!
Stable Hearth
33-35 Duke Street, Darlington, DL3 7RX
The romantic vibes of this spot will be hard to beat. Tucked away on Duke Street in Darlington, Stable Hearth offers Neapolitan wood fired pizzas, giving them a gorgeously squidgy crust and thin centre. The pizza menu covers three pages, so you definitely aren’t short of options, with fan favourites like pepperoni, to more unique choices like the Deputy Dog with a pumpkin puree base. The open kitchen adds to the atmosphere, so make sure you try to bag a table close by!
Cena Trattoria
85 High Street, Yarm, TS15 9BG
Cena brings the sophistication of a modern Italian trattoria to Yarm High Street, serving fresh, seasonal dishes made with authentic ingredients. Visit at lunchtime to enjoy the light, airy space, or settle in during the evening for a cosy, candlelit atmosphere. Their expertly crafted pizzas cater to everyone, from meat lovers to vegetarians and vegans, including a standout Mediterranean vegetable option. With an extensive menu and plenty of choice, it’s an excellent spot for family dinners. Even the fussiest eaters will find something to love!
No. Twenty Three
23 Milton Street, Saltburn, TS12 1DJ
A day in Saltburn isn’t complete without a visit to No. Twenty Three. This popular spot serves up Neapolitan style pizzas alongside craft beers and an impressive gin selection, so it’s a fantastic pick for an evening. The decor combines a plush, rich feel with industrial elements, and when you add that to the foldable slices with doughy crusts, you’re on to a winner. Don’t miss out on the special boards – there’s always the most mouthwatering choices on there!
Picco
20 Bondgate, Darlington, DL3 7JE
Picco is a well-loved spot in Darlington, best known for its stonebaked, thin crust pizzas loaded with both classic and more adventurous toppings. Whether you’re in the mood for a spicy Diavola, a rich and cheesy Quattro Formaggi, or the house favourite Picco Special topped with prosciutto and rocket, there’s something for every pizza lover. With its relaxed, no-frills atmosphere and consistently good food, it’s an ideal choice for a laidback meal that still delivers on flavour.
Base
125 High Street, Marske, TS11 6JX
At a glance, Marske is a quaint coastal town, but there are some brilliant gems to find there, like Base. This is one for the Neapolitan pizza fans – think thin bases, fluffy crusts and perfectly charred blisters that beg to be dunked in one of the many dips. Team up a pizza with a selection of small plates between your group, then walk it off on the beach, which is conveniently a short walk down the road!
Subscribe
Subscribe now to receive our twice-weekly emails and exclusive offers for High Life North readers.